Showing posts with label Public Advocate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Public Advocate. Show all posts

Friday, October 12, 2012

GAZETTE COLUMN: ON DELGAUDIO – THE BOARD MISSED ITS CHANCE by John P. Flannery



The Board of Supervisors missed its chance to avoid the stain that Supervisor Eugene Delgaudio casts on this Board and this fine County.

Chairman Scott York issued a statement that the Board intended to look into Mr. Delgaudio’s alleged misconduct, presumably involving fund-raising on County time, among the other things that Mr. Delgaudio’s been accused of doing.  On this score, Mr. Delgaudio admitted that he did raise funds on County time at the last Board meeting.

Chairman York’s announcement of an investigation could have been encouraging except for the fact that there’s hardly anything “independent” about the investigation that the Board ultimately authorized unanimously, 9-0, including, yes, Mr. Delgaudio’s own vote supporting the investigation. 

The Board is going to have its County Attorney select the “independent” prosecutor and pay the “independent” prosecutor a whopping $15,000 to conduct this “impartial” investigation.  Really?  The Board should appreciate how characterizing this underfunded appointment by its own counsel as “independent” is suspect.

Nor can we ignore, in this regard, when evaluating the Board’s efforts, what Chairman York said he’s done already to have this matter “investigated.”  Chairman York said that in March of this year, he referred charges against Supervisor Eugene Delgaudio including, we presume, Mr. Delgaudio’s alleged misappropriation of public services.  He sent “the matter,” he said, to the Loudoun County Commonwealth Attorney, Jim Plowman, who was Supervisor Delgaudio's Loudoun County election ticket mate.  So, the referral was problematic from the start.

In addition, Chairman York chose this “confidential” referral route rather than convening a public meeting of the Board.  Why no public meeting in March?  Why only last week?  Was it because Chairman York had the scent of the Washington Post investigation in March when it was not the widely circulated expose it’s become?  Under these circumstances, the referral looks more like an effort to protect instead of to detect anything questionable about Mr. Delgaudio’s conduct.

Mr. Plowman, in turn, forwarded “the matter,” according to Chairman York, to the Arlington Commonwealth Attorney who, York says, found no violation.  No violation!  Wow!  I’m a former federal and state prosecutor from New York and you can’t get a local prosecutor to clear a traffic ticket, much less an elected official in a corruption investigation. 

What information and what questions did Chairman York present to Mr. Plowman and the Arlington Commonwealth Attorney?

Did they ask whether there was an unlawful misappropriation of public funds when Mr. Delgaudio and his County employees conducted fundraising on county time at taxpayers’ expense?

Did they ask what representations Mr. Delgaudio made to the County, if any, in connection with reimbursed expenses by the County for fundraising seminars that his County staff attended?

Did they ask whether it was a violation for Mr. Delgaudio to blend his responsibility to the County as an elected official with his leadership of Public Advocate, charged with copyright violations?

We know too little about the “investigation” to date.  But we do know that the process in place is suspect because of what preceded the Board’s belated public disclosures – after the Post stories appeared. 

The resolution is simple – the Chairman and Board of Supervisors should go back to the drawing board, get it right this time, and petition a truly independent body, perhaps the courts, so that we appoint someone truly “independent,” rather than someone underfunded and compromised ethically right out of the gate.

We require an investigation that is truly fair, vigorous and public that gets at what really happened.

Otherwise, we are underwriting a process that will surely guarantee our beloved County another ration of ridicule and embarrassment.

Saturday, October 6, 2012

GAZETTE COLUMN: OPEN LETTER TO BOS – TIME TO CLEAN UP DELGAUDIO’S ACT by John P. Flannery

Supervisor Delgaudio - and a few of his like-minded friends



Dear Chairman and Members of the Loudoun County Board of Supervisors exclusive of Sterling Supervisor, Eugene Delgaudio,

It’s high time that this Board of Supervisors took a long hard look at Mr. Delgaudio’s alleged misconduct. 

The Southern Poverty Law Center charged recently that Delgaudio headed a gay-bashing hate group called Public Advocate.

Last week, we read reports that Hannah Scoggins, of Public Advocate, that same hate group, was telling Delgaudio’s County staffers what to do, rather than another Senior County employee or the Supervisor himself.

We also learned that Mr. Delgaudio had allegedly misappropriated a private copyrighted wedding picture of a same sex marriage, altered the photo and ridiculed the couple in an out of state political campaign. 

More than that, we’re told that Delgaudio, after a most inappropriate job interviewing process, made it a condition of employment for his county staff, one worker in particular who came forward to talk about this publicly, to raise money for Delgaudio’s political and “charitable” campaigns while working on County time on our tax dime. 

There are reportedly e-mails, contribution lists, and documents, that support these charges, and I have filed a Freedom of Information Act, to see these materials for myself; I understand other citizens have and are doing the same because they’re not sure you’re going to do what’s necessary. 

I do not believe that this is a partisan issue.

I believe both parties and independents see this as a good government issue – as the alleged misconduct violates ordinary standards of decency and tolerance and the proper use of a public office.
While I may disagree with Board Members who oppose same sex marriage, that is a different discussion than the gay bashing, and hateful bigoted speech that Delgaudio spews relentlessly.
Each other Board member’s skin must crawl when Delgaudio renders one of his indecent rants, and you’re associated because you serve with this relic of Old South intolerance.  Bigotry is a category of free speech that should guarantee a seat in the audience once spoken, rather than on the dais as an elected official.

Raising the necessary funds to run for office is an onerous and complex undertaking.  But there are some bright lines when fund-raising is not allowed.  No elected official may rely on his taxpayer paid staffers to call for political or charitable contributions when the staffer is on the county clock, on County time. 

We presume, for this letter and for all time, that no member of this Board supports bigotry, nor believes that an outside hate group should direct campaign staff, or condones the use of public staff to raise campaign or charitable funds, and the misappropriation of public resources.

Accordingly, I most respectfully insist that this Board should ban hateful rhetoric from its chamber and by any elected official who purports to represent the citizens of this County on the Board, not only what Delgaudio has said and done in the past but what we can expect he will continue to do.

Accordingly, this Board should also ban – at the very least - outside hate groups from directing the conduct of our public employees.

Accordingly, this Board should force Mr. Delgaudio to refund every penny of taxpayer funds, if found to be misspent and misappropriated for his fund-raising activities, and, if Delgaudio resists, then you should take him to court and seek a money judgment against him, and deposit the proceeds in the County Treasury.

Accordingly, this Board should refer any criminal charges, should any be confirmed, to a special prosecutor appointed by the Court.

This Board should establish the kind of machinery that the Congress has on its ethics committee to handle such matters in the future but, in the meantime, should these charges be found true, Mr. Delgaudio should be disciplined including but not limited to removing him from any and all leadership position(s) on the Board of Supervisors and on its various Committees.

The Board, like our community, has only just been informed of the breadth of Mr. Delgaudio’s misconduct.  If this Board doesn’t want to be tarred with the same brush, by tolerating his misconduct, it must act firmly and swiftly. 

These recent published reports have prompted another rash of head-slapping questions about what mind-altering substance could possibly exist in Loudoun County’s drinking water that would permit a Delgaudio to be elected to anything.

This Board of Supervisors must draw the line between robust free speech and bigotry, also between legitimate fund-raising and the misappropriation of public services.

This Board must do what’s necessary, hold hearings, examine the evidence, take Delgaudio’s testimony in public, and act upon the findings. 

Studied indifference is not an acceptable response.