Showing posts with label Mitt Romney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mitt Romney. Show all posts

Thursday, September 27, 2012

GAZETTE COLUMN: ROMNEY - THE INELEGANT PLUTOCRAT by John P. Flannery

Republican Presidential Candidate Mitt Romney infamously said recently that 47% of our citizens "believe they are entitled to health care, to food, to housing, you name it." 

Romney therefore doesn’t believe in providing any public assistance to the ill, the hungry, or the homeless?  Perhaps Anatole France captured Mitt’s understanding when he wrote: “The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to get in the streets, and to steal bread.”  On the question of stealing bread, do we think Mitt would have imprisoned Jean Valjean for stealing a loaf of bread to feed his starving sister and family (see Victor Hugo’s Les Miserables )?

Romney further complained that these folk who think they are “entitled” are people who pay no income tax." Romney said, "my job is not to worry about these people.  I'll never convince them they should take personal responsibility and care for their lives."

Wow.  What a political buzz kill for all those people who thought this guy was going to get them jobs so that they could earn money and pay taxes. 

Perhaps, Romney, the profit sucking predator of those companies he liquidated for profits, revealed his true “Mr. Hide” side more candidly because he was “with his true friends.”

Romney likely thought he was enveloped in a cone of silence addressing other wealthy plutocrats at a dinner that cost each a political contribution as much as an upscale motor home.

Romney spoke to those who “think” like he does, in this disparaging way, that those not paying federal income taxes are not taking responsibility and caring for their lives. 

The 47% that Romney is talking about are mostly working poor, children, mothers, young adults, those who lost their jobs in the recession, the disabled, seniors, servicemen and service women.  

Is “Romney the Indifferent” saying that a student who doesn’t pay income taxes is failing to take personal responsibility, or a retiree who collects social security, or a person on unemployment who lost a job because his company failed because of shoddy banking practices?

Romney should know that the student, mother or senior who doesn’t pay income taxes pays payroll taxes (for Social Security and Medicare).  

But Romney thinks these are undeserved “entitlements,” though these men and women paid hard cash in advance of their senior years for Social Security and Medicare, and the government now has an “obligation” to pay what it promised.  Vice Presidential Candidate, Paul Ryan, the Mini-Mitt, got booed by the AARP because he advanced this line of reasoning publicly, that Romney would reform Social Security, Medicare and Health Care. 

Not incidentally, those who don't pay federal taxes, also pay sales, excise and property taxes.

Romney the plutocrat sees takers and parasitic moochers.  It’s like those bright intensely colored pictures of images you used to find in cereal boxes.  You’d stare at them for a while until they were imprinted on your cerebral cortex, you’d close your eyes, and then, when you looked at a blank wall, you’d see that same image, almost wherever you looked even though it was only trapped in your mind – and didn’t really exist.  Romney got this fixed image of his and he sees anyone who doesn’t pay taxes as a moocher.

Romney is worth between $190 and $250 million dollars, and earned about 13 million dollars last year, and paid only about 14% in taxes, less than many middle class taxpayers including teachers, cops and construction workers; that makes Romney more like a taker; Warren Buffett said no wealthy person should pay less than most middle class Americans; Romney doesn’t agree.

Romney got busted making these remarks making him the leading candidate for the summertime Scrooge award, for the most non-empathetic candidate this presidential season.

When caught, Romney raced to a microphone to say he’d been “inelegant.”  If he’d known we’d find out, he would have said it differently.  He asked, are we going to believe our lying eyes and ears or what he tells us to believe.

I believe that Mitt, who is himself well-housed, and well fed, has been caught saying aloud what the current Republican Party believes.

Herman Melville wrote, “Of all the preposterous assumptions of humanity over humanity, nothing exceeds most of the criticisms made on the habits of the poor by the well-housed, well-warmed, and well-fed.”

Mitt offers this nation a dark vision and a sorry legacy – and the strongest evidence is his own words.

Thursday, September 13, 2012

COLUMN: OBAMA’S VISION OF “SHARED PROSPERITY” AND REPUBLICAN MYOPIA by John P. Flannery

President Barack Obama addressed the democratic convention last Thursday evening advocating a “new vision of America in which prosperity is shared.”

That’s democracy, small “d,” the sentiment that “we are all in this together.”  Our inscribed nation’s seal bears the inscription, “e pluribus unum,” meaning, “out of many, one.”  Our American constitution embraces, “We the people of the United States,” meaning all of us.  We formed a Constitution because the confederation of separate states lacked the shared strength for this nation’s survival and the need to provide and promote for its general welfare. 

Our government is a reflection of our human condition, as John Donne said, that “no man is an island, entire of itself,” and that each of us “is a piece of the continent, a part of the main.”

That’s why I was taken aback by the Republican reaction to the President’s vision of “shared prosperity.”

Driving east of the Cape Fear River in North Carolina past a tobacco field on our way toward Creedmor, we heard a local Republican Congressional Challenger for the Fourth Congressional District, Tim D’Annunzio, attack the President’s “vision” in a freshly minted radio ad.
D’Annunzio said the President’s “vision” was a “deceptive way of saying his future includes more socialism.  And it’s a perverted version of the American Dream.” (Listen for yourself: http://www.timvote.com/media/ )

My wife, Holly, and step-daughter, Alex, couldn’t imagine how our constitutional principles could be considered a “deceptive way.”
D’Annunzio nevertheless insisted that the President’s vision of “shared prosperity” would lead us “to national decline, chronic unemployment and the cannibalization of national wealth.” 

D’Annuzio’s fractured view is that, when the Declaration of Independence says we have “the right to pursue happiness,” we are otherwise on our own.  Tim should have read the Declaration of Independence more carefully including the rudimentary principle that “Governments are instituted among Men…” in order “to secure these rights” including the right to pursue happiness.

Cognitive dissonance is a term from psychology where a person or party holds conflicting beliefs, irreconcilably contradictory, at the same time, causing a feeling of guilt or anger. 

We know Republican leaders, as well as friends and neighbors, who say they can do it on their own without government but, in their individual daily lives, that’s not what they do; they seek out other friends and neighbors to share responsibility to mutual advantage on an array of projects.

How do our leaders and friends reconcile claiming they need no help from government but expecting aid and comfort from friends and neighbors? 
More to the point, how are they able to disregard the fact that they accept and expect help from the government as well.

When we consider more closely all these individuals who claim they can exist native, rugged, without any government assistance, we see that they drive on highways we all pay for, use water and waste systems shared with others, enjoy community supported fire and police protection, their children attend public schools, are protected by our national defense, use weather and satellite information, and so many other services they take for granted, seemingly  ignored as factually irrelevant, by atomistic Ayn-Randish citizens, who insist they need no one else, but especially no government.

This cognitive dissonance, they call independence, is really about indifference to our national challenges.

Consider the contradictory Republican messages this presidential season when Republican leaders and supporters claim they are for creating jobs by forgiving taxes to the wealthy who have created no jobs previously while they otherwise resist any jobs program that would get this nation back to work.  They say they care for the unemployed, the homeless and the hungry, but lift not a finger to lighten their load, even slandering families that feed their families with food stamps.  They are the party of women we are told even as they dictate to women what they may do with their own bodies.  They support the right to vote but suppress it with legislation calculated to restrict access to the voting booth among seniors, minorities, students, and the poor.   They are for an all-inclusive nation but resist pluralism and would cast out immigrant children who have never lived elsewhere.   They proclaim proudly, in one breath, how this nation is exceptional, and, in the next, they bash and trash our nation top to bottom.

We can’t expect a winning plan for our nation from a party that doesn’t know its own mind.  Republican Presidential nominee, Mitt Romney, said, if elected, he’ll take 8 years to balance the budget.  President Obama has a head start on a plan in place to clean up the mess that President Bush created.  Let’s stay the course.

Friday, September 7, 2012

COLUMN: THE REPUBLICAN CONFECTION by John P. Flannery

Eastwood Unplugged

We’ve grown numb to the unworthy process of cage fighting pols busting each other with unsubstantiated slanders and impossible policy claims.

Romney’s campaign team has just finished regaling us with their “vision” of America as seen from Tampa, Florida. 

Congressman Paul Ryan, the Republican Vice Presidential candidate, charged that a sensational factory closing in his home town, Janesville, Wisconsin, arose because of Barack Obama’s failed promise to keep it open; in truth, GM announced the closing in June 2008 because of sagging SUV sales while Bush was President.  

Ryan charged that S&P downgraded U.S. debt because of Obama when it was the Republicans in Congress including budget maven Ryan who refused to raise the debt ceiling until the last minute.
Former Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice claimed street cred’ for international neophytes Romney and Ryan.  She overlooked the war in Afghanistan.  No doubt that was because President Obama’s administration found and killed Osama Bin Laden when Bush and Rice could not find him or the chimerical weapons of mass destruction they posited as the reason to invade Iraq.

Romney needed an assist on his foreign policy acumen given how he botched what should have been no more complicated than a walk in Hyde park.  Romney dissed his Olympic hosts in Great Britain and couldn’t keep secret he had also met with British military intelligence.  In Israel, he eagerly signed onto Netanyahu’s forced march to Teheran, apparently relinquishing America’s prerogative to refuse another preemptive war.

New Jersey Governor Chris Christy, a bombastic blow bag, warmed to a litany of his own “accomplishments,” but could hardly bring himself to mention Romney, the presidential nominee.
Ann Romney talked about her husband, the nominee, because we don’t see him the way she does.   

And we still don’t see him that way. 

Frankly, who cares if Mitt is charming if he can persuade us that he’d make a make a difference for the better.     

Romney tells older American they won’t lose their social security, just the younger adults who fund their retirement, suggesting the Romney social security system is not so secure.

Romney tells the sick they should have planned better and must learn how to take care of themselves -- even though presidents, senators and congressmen don’t.

It’s hard to believe Romney’s policies will add a single job when he’s for firing public employees including teachers, refusing unemployment insurance, rejecting public job training, and resisting public works projects that would repair our declining national infrastructure and put men and women to work.

Romney repeats the cant that by collecting less taxes from the filthy rich, they’ll create the jobs they failed to create when Bush gave them an earlier tax holiday.

There is an abiding selfishness in the Republican platform disfavoring the middle class

By contrast, Democrats believe we are in this together to help each other.

Pope Leo believed that the role of the State was to promote social justice through the protection of rights.  The modern Republican party denies any such responsibility.

Pope Leo insisted workers have bargaining rights to defend against unbridled capitalism.  The Republican party doesn’t see it that way.

Leo said, “If through necessity or fear of a worse evil the workman accept harder conditions because an employer or contractor will afford him no better, he is made the victim of force and injustice.”  In this recession, we have seen families with jobs that paid less and suffered indignities by employers who knew their workers had few, if any, alternatives.

The current Republican Party compromises the working man and woman for their business’ bottom line.

We’ll do better with President Barack Obama.

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

COLUMN: “PRESIDENT” PAUL RYAN AND HIS PATRON by John P. Flannery

Ryan getting ready to hold us up.


Mark Twain said that, while “history doesn’t repeat itself, it does rhyme.”  The arrogance of politicians is the unalterable belief that the outcome will be different for them.
Four years ago, Senator John McCain, a ‘Nam hero because he was held prisoner at the “Hanoi Hilton” after crashing his plane was imprisoned again but this time, in 2008, it was by the far right wing of his own party. 
The party muzzled John’s celebrated rogue manner, especially his inconvenient campaign finance reforms, and forced him to choose a not-ready-for-prime-time running mate from Alaska, Governor Sarah Palin, who didn’t know what she didn’t know, not even the constitutional provision that defined her job as VP.  Palin couldn’t name any publication she read to keep informed, and her myopic view of foreign affairs, she bragged, was the sight line from her back porch through the Aleutians to the Russian shore.  Palin prompted an incurable national epidemic of confidence jitters at the slimmest possibility that she might ever have to succeed the senior McCain as President.
This year we have former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney promising us 12 million jobs that will appear, as if by magic, if we allow him to implement his “secret plan,” can you smell the snake oil, once he’s elected, oh yeah.  You can hear the barker at the carney, “step right up and give up your tax money to save the wealthiest from paying taxes, and your rich friends will deign to rain down upon you whatever excess monies they don’t need, even go so far as to hire you middle class folk – although you may have to move offshore to Bangalore to work.”  The words of a seeming angel cast a veil over the face of the devil.
Mitt announced his running mate, his doppelganger some say, another nationally unproven tyro from the far right, Congressman Paul Ryan, an Ayn Rand cultist devotee (who rankles at Rand’s atheism but loves her take-no-prisoner Darwinian capitalism).  Paul has passed only two bills of his own in Congress in thirteen years, but he’s been busy as a beaver more recently proposing a budget bill the bane of seniors nationwide who fear the loss of Medicare and Medicaid benefits.  This was hardly the book move for a presidential candidate, going around scaring the bejesus out of all those retirees in the nation and in Florida – a critical battleground state for the White House.  Mitt’s campaign drifted into a current running against him, so he had to “do something.” McCain thought the same thing in 2008.
I truly believe Romney recognized he’d lost the nomination as he wanted it, on his own terms, when he made the (Freudian) slip, announcing Ryan as the “next President of the United States.”
If Romney has a recognizable philosophy, it may not be what he needs to get the nomination. 
Romney is a lot like Senator Bob Dole who broke the indoor speed record for crossing the political spectrum, with a Guinness world record of inconsistent policy statements, just like Mitt, from the more neutral shades to far right red to land the nomination.  President Bill Clinton then pinned Dole down in the far right corner never letting the Dole of the rightward countenance to move toward the middle where the nation’s votes live in a general election.  It was a rout for Clinton that November. 
Now, I’m not saying that what Romney has done, in his R1-R2 strategy, will lead to a free fall failure as it did for Dole – I am prepared, however, to watch the bleeding begin.

Friday, February 17, 2012

GAZETTE COLUMN: MITT’S MIND BLINDNESS TO POVERTY by John P. Flannery

Republican Presidential candidate Mitt Romney doesn’t consider “the poor” part of his mission as president if he’s elected.  The lips of Lady Liberty, inviting the world, “Give me your tired, your poor,” are words unheard by Mitt.
The poor have a safety net, Mitt says.  But not too long ago he said the safety net didn’t work meaning it didn’t help – and therefore wasn’t needed – and there was just too much overhead he said – though the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities says that as much as 99 percent of the dollars set aside for the poor are actually spent on the poor.
Mitt is a well-oiled political weather vane spinning wildly in the winds of public opinion.  Republican activists and Independents fear he is an invertebrate without any principles at the center that one could mistake for political character.  In a recent turn in the news spin cycle, Mitt was caught up short for his hard hearted indifference toward the poor.  He back-filled saying that he’d “fix” the safety net if it needed fixing – the net that he had found unnecessary.
Mitt’s mind is blind to the fact that our “safety net” is not only necessary but it falls short and is past due for a fix for the one in six poor who go hungry, and a third of the poor who have no health insurance.  Incidentally, Mitt wants to cut a few holes in the health insurance net by reducing Medicaid.   Not the kind of “fix” you’d expect from someone who cares about the poor.
You might think Mitt made the calculation that the poor don’t vote – and that the nation doesn’t care about the poor.  But I believe we are all better than that and it explains why Mitt scrambled to explain that he “misspoke.”
Perhaps Mitt thought he was merely topping the chorus of the callous.  Republican Presidential primary candidate, Speaker Newt Gingrich, thought it was funny that so many must rely on food stamps so they don’t go hungry. 
There is this absurd Dickensian projection embraced by the unfeeling, Mitt and Newt included, that gives them some solace, the belief that all poor are malingerers, faking hunger, homelessness, and illness.  Mitt and Newt want us to believe that the poor really could work and earn a living – if they just chose to do so.
Mitt says he favors the middle class.  If so, he ignores the fact that the shrinking fractional proportion of our polity that is the middle class is not being promoted into Mitt’s nether regions of scandalous investment incomes.  The middle class shrinkage means some of us are joining the poor, losing our jobs, home, health care and retirement.
By contrast, the social contract that has worked for this still young democracy is to promote the good life for one and all by encouraging wealth, but also while creating a climate of public and private incentives favoring jobs for the middle class and transfer payments for the poor.
Our society is out of whack.  The true class warfare is the notion that any group has gotten “its own” and the other segments of society must fend for themselves.  Many of the rich get it.  Mitt is not one of those.
Mitt should read the Book of Mormon more carefully for there it is written:
“But wo unto the rich who are rich as to the things of the world.  For because they are rich they despise the poor, and they persecute the meek and their hearts are upon their treasures; wherefore, their treasure is their god.  And behold their treasure shall perish with them also.”  2 NEPHI 9:30.
So may his candidacy perish -- if not before Tampa then in November!